Valuable Items Insurance in Orlando & Central Florida
Your treasured possessions deserve more than a standard policy. We craft specialized coverage that protects the things you have spent a lifetime collecting and cherishing.
Why Standard Homeowners Insurance Falls Short
Most homeowners policies include strict sub-limits on valuables such as jewelry, fine art, wine collections, antiques, and musical instruments. A standard policy might cap jewelry coverage at $1,500 or exclude fine art breakage entirely. These limitations leave significant gaps that could cost you thousands in the event of a loss.
Common exclusions include mysterious disappearance, accidental breakage, and flood or earthquake damage to collectibles. If your possessions have appreciated in value since you purchased them, a standard policy may only reimburse the original purchase price rather than the current market or replacement value.
Scheduled vs. Blanket Coverage
Scheduled Coverage
Each item is individually listed and appraised on your policy. This approach guarantees an agreed-upon payout for every piece, eliminating disputes at claim time. Ideal for high-value single items like engagement rings, statement artwork, or vintage instruments.
Blanket Coverage
A single coverage limit applies to an entire category of items, providing flexibility without the need to appraise every individual piece. This is well suited for growing collections where items are frequently added, such as wine cellars, coin collections, or book libraries.
What Can Be Insured
From priceless heirlooms to modern collectibles, we protect the full spectrum of your valued possessions.
Jewelry & Watches
Engagement rings, luxury timepieces, heirloom pieces, and designer jewelry protected against loss, theft, and accidental damage.
Fine Art
Paintings, sculptures, prints, and photography collections covered for their full appraised value with worldwide protection.
Wine Collections
Rare vintages and curated cellars insured against breakage, spoilage, temperature failure, and theft.
Collectibles & Antiques
Musical instruments, antique furniture, rare books, coins, stamps, and other prized collections safeguarded with tailored coverage.
Why Choose Portilla
We go beyond placing a policy. Our team ensures every item is properly valued, every risk is addressed, and every claim is handled with care.
Expert Valuation Guidance
We help you establish accurate, up-to-date appraisals so your coverage reflects the true replacement value of every item in your collection.
Specialized Carriers
As an independent agency, we partner with carriers that specialize in high-value personal property, giving you access to broader coverage and more favorable terms.
Comprehensive Protection
From agreed-value settlements to worldwide coverage and no deductibles, we build policies that eliminate the gaps standard insurance leaves behind.
Valuable Items Insurance FAQs
How scheduled personal property coverage protects what your homeowners policy won't.
Why do I need valuable items insurance if I already have homeowners?
Standard homeowners policies cap jewelry coverage at around $1,500–$2,500 total, with similar sub-limits for fine art, silverware, firearms, and collectibles. They also exclude 'mysterious disappearance' (a lost ring without explanation) and often exclude accidental breakage. Scheduled valuable items insurance replaces those sub-limits with agreed-value, broader-peril coverage — typically with no deductible.
What's the difference between scheduled and blanket coverage?
Scheduled coverage lists each item individually with its appraised or receipted value. Payouts are agreed-value with no depreciation. Blanket coverage applies a single limit across a category (e.g., $25,000 for jewelry) without listing each piece. Scheduled is best for high-value single items (engagement rings, signature artwork); blanket works for growing collections (wine, coins, books).
Do I need an appraisal for jewelry and valuables?
For pieces above roughly $5,000, yes — most carriers require a recent appraisal (generally within the last 3–5 years). For lower-value items, a detailed receipt is often sufficient. We'll tell you exactly what the carrier needs before you pay for an appraisal you don't actually need.
Does valuable items insurance cover loss worldwide?
Yes — most scheduled personal property policies provide worldwide coverage, so your engagement ring is protected on vacation, your fine art is covered in transit, and your watch is covered at the office. Read the fine print on high-risk activities (scuba diving with a ring, for example) — we'll flag carrier-specific exclusions before you bind.
Is there a deductible on valuable items insurance?
Typically no. Most scheduled personal property policies have a $0 deductible on covered losses — that's a key advantage over filing through your homeowners policy, which has a substantial deductible (often $2,500+ in Florida).
What items can I schedule on a valuable items policy?
Common categories include jewelry and watches, fine art and prints, silverware and china, antiques and collectibles, firearms, musical instruments, wine collections, rare books, coins and stamps, and cameras. If it has real value and a standard homeowners policy limits or excludes it, we can typically schedule it.
Protect What You Treasure Most
Whether it is a single heirloom or an entire collection, we will design coverage that gives you complete peace of mind. Get in touch today for a complimentary review.
Request My Free Quote